Non-Vacuum Electron Beam Welding with the Plasma Arc Window
On
April 29, 2004 Acceleron LLC demonstrated to the DOE and NU non-vacuum
electron
beam welding with an electron beam that was transmitted
from machine vacuum to atmosphere through the plasma window. The
attendees were able to witness that Acceleron has successfully
accomplished electron beam welding with this new technology. During
the demonstration we welded 3 consecutive samples that showed repeatable
results. The non-vacuum welding was performed with a low-power electron
beam welder (6 kW), which in itself is quite remarkable.
At
this point, we feel that the
plasma window technology has reached a level of
maturity, where the next natural step is to convert one
of our main production
high-power welders (25 kW) to non-vacuum operation. Once this has been
completed and its results are repeatable, we will begin to weld with this
new technology on a production basis. We expect this to happen within this
year.
During
our discussions after the weld demonstration, we shared with all
the attendees some of the additional advantages and further
success this new technology can bring along with other testing
that needs to be done in order to better sell this technology to
the market place. The first encouraging news we have is that the
initial weld results are much better than what Ady Hershcovitch
anticipated. The welds are more narrow and deeper with the amount
of power used
to produce these welds. "After just 2 weeks of weld development
the welds are truly of text book geometry," he reported. To date
each time we have made a design change to the Arc itself, or to
the differential
pumping section, we continue to witness further improvements to
the weld and its geometry. This is not to say that all changes
will have a positive result, but it does show that we are on the
right track with optimizing the complete system for the best possible
results. As anticipated, we have been able to greatly reduce the
amount of energy required with our system set up and the use of
the Plasma
Arc Window verses the Non-Vacuum systems used today, see the details
below for more information.
Perhaps
the most exciting new development from this program to date is
the possibility of Plasma projection. This
new invention is currently being written and the patent
application will soon be submitted. This new technology will allow for "Plasma
Shielding for In-Air and Under-Water Beam Processes."
Our
next goals include further development using the existing 7.5
kW EB machine to optimize differential pumping and Arc design.
While this is in progress our team will continue with their experiments
to continue with the Arc projection bench testing. In conjunction
with the Arc projection testing, we will also continue to improve
our system design and begin to build a third Plasma Arc with the
changes that have been learned. While the third Arc is being built,
we will begin to modify our high-power 25 kW machine to do more
accurate weld comparisons to the machines used in today's
industries. This next test is imperative so
that we can show side-by-side weld comparisons at the same power
levels and processing speeds. Once this has been completed, we
will then begin welding with this new technology on a production
basis.
Note: We
visited Thomas W. Eagar, Sc.D., P.E. at MIT on June 7, 2004.
Tom is Head of the Materials Science and Engineering Department.
We brought weld samples and photos for his evaluation and review.
He was quite impressed with the weld and its geometry and has
since sent us a letter with his comments. Click
here to view his comments and credentials (PDF, 144k). |

#1
Vacuum Differential Pumping
Efficient
Vacuum Differential Pumping equates to less energy consumption,
resulting in large cost savings in the operation of the electron
beam non-vacuum welding process. One of the major goals is to achieve
a satisfactory separation and preservation of the high vacuum area
where the electron beam itself is generated, while enabling its
transmission to atmosphere. To date, results have confirmed that
we have attained excellent electron beam transmission. The accomplishment
of this endeavor in itself has shown results that have significantly
more advanced vacuum separation than conventional non-vacuum EB
welds. The improved vacuum stages that are necessary for vacuum
separation are attributed to one of the functions that the Plasma
Arc Window
offers. Most of today's non-vacuum machines typically require
a total pumping capacity of approximately 3200 CFM to attain necessary
separation. The Plasma Arc Window is providing far better energy
consumption results with only 42 CFM, or 91.5% less energy consumption.
Advantages
and cost savings over conventional non-vacuum electron beam welding
machines are:
| • |
Current
overall total required energy is 70% more energy efficient |
| • |
90%
reduction in floor space, allotted for vacuum pumps |
| • |
Significant
noise reduction due to the elimination of large vacuum pumps |
Note:
Other technical advantages have been omitted until the results have been measured.
The
major goals of this development are to:
| A. |
Be
at least 80% more energy efficient than conventional EB and
Laser machines today. |
| B. |
Replace
energy inefficient technologies with the same or better weld
results. |
| C. |
Decrease
current welding costs of high-density welding. |
| D. |
Replicate
a high-voltage, high-vacuum EB weld as best as possible. |
| E. |
Make
this new technology mobile so that it can be used on a robot
or other motion type systems. |
| F. |
Weld,
drill and possibly cut and machine. |
| G. |
Decrease
floor space and cost of current EB high- and non-vacuum EB machines. |
| H. |
Commercialize
and sell this new technology as a retrofit to existing machines
and incorporate
into new equipment. |
| I. |
Find
other applications outside the welding industry. |
Marketing,
Inquiries and related information
| • |
One
Plasma Arc unit has been sold to a research and engineering
firm within the U.S. |
| • |
Acceleron Newsletters |
| • |
AcceleronInc.com
news item – Acceleron
Wins Grant from the U.S. Department of Energy to Commercialize
New Welding Technique Developed at
Brookhaven Lab |
| • |
New
Scientist magazine - article published in the April, 2003 issue |
| • |
New
Scientist magazine – follow-up article published
in July, 2004 |
| • |
Gateway
- article
published January, 2004 (PDF, 1.3mb) |
| • |
Gateway – follow-up
article for July, 2004 (PDF, 76k) |
| • |
Machine
Design - article published July 8, 2004 – download
PDF (1.5mb) or read
online at Machine Design's web site |
| • |
Industry
Week - "Emerging
Technologies" feature published October, 2004 (PDF,
116k) |
| • |
The
Welding Journal / American Welding Society - Technology
feature published January, 2005 (PDF, 276k) |
| • |
APS
News / American Physical Society - feature
published January, 2005 (PDF, 80k) |
| • |
American
Institute of Physics - white
paper published online April, 2005 (PDF,
580k) |
| • |
American
Scientist -
feature
application story, July-August, 2005 (PDF,
244k) |
To
date we are talking to four separate companies that have interest
in this new technology. There are two companies in Germany, one
in Spain and one in the United Kingdom. Two of the four companies
have requested and received quotes for one of these units.
Technical
articles authored and co-authored by Brookhaven National Labratory
scientist Ady Hershcovitch
| 4/95 |
Journal
of Applied Physics, Vol. 78, No. 9 – High-pressure
arcs as vacuum-atmosphere interface and plasma lens for nonvacuum
electron beam welding machines, electron beam melting, and
nonvacuum ion material modification (PDF,
644k) |
| 1/98 |
Physics
of Plasmas, Vol. 5, No. 5 – A
plasma window for transmission of particle beams and radiation
from vacuum to atmosphere for
various applications (PDF,
164k) |
| 6/00 |
Review
of Scientific Instruments, Vol. 72, No. 3 – X-ray
transmission through a plasma window (PDF,
56k) |
| 10/00 |
Nuclear
Instruments and Methods in Physics Research – Windowless
targets for intense beams (PDF, 220k) |
| 4/02 |
Spallation
Neutron Source – Plasma
Window for SNS Target (PDF, 464k) |
| 4/05 |
American
Institute of Physics – Air
boring and nonvacuum electron beam welding with a plasma window (PDF,
580k) |
| 8/05 |
Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research – Non-vacuum electron beam welding through a plasma window (PDF,
192k) |
|